Solar Hot Water Systems vs Gas Hot Water Systems

When Brisbane homeowners need to install a new hot water system, we at Mitchell Plumbing & Gas know that choosing between solar and gas options can be tricky. Solar hot water systems use the sun's energy to heat your water, while gas hot water systems burn natural gas or LPG to warm up your home's water supply.

These two systems work in completely different ways, which means they each have their own set of advantages and trade-offs. To help you make the best choice for your home, we look at how they compare across several important areas:

• Energy Use: Solar hot water systems tap into free sunlight to heat your water, while gas hot water systems need a steady supply of gas. This affects both your energy bills and environmental impact.
• Installation Costs: The upfront price of putting in each hot water system can vary quite a bit. Solar hot water systems often cost more to install at first, but they can save money over time.
• Maintenance Needs: Each hot water system needs different kinds of care to keep running well. Some parts might need checking or replacing more often than others.
• How Long They Last: Different hot water systems have different lifespans, which affects their long-term value for your home.
• Noise Levels: Some hot water systems are quieter than others, which matters if the unit will be near bedrooms or living areas.
• Heat-Up Speed: The time it takes to get hot water flowing through your taps varies between hot water systems. This affects how quickly you can have a hot shower or run the dishwasher.

‍

What Is a Solar Hot Water System?

A solar hot water system turns sunlight into heat for your home's water supply. The hot water system works by having solar collectors (panels) on your roof that soak up the sun's rays. These panels have special tubes or flat plates that heat up the water as it moves through them. The heated water then flows down to a storage tank, where it stays hot until you need it.

The main parts of a solar hot water system are:

• Solar panels that catch the sun's energy
• A well-insulated storage tank to keep the water hot
• Backup electric or gas boosters for cloudy days
• Pipes that connect everything together

‍

What Is a Gas Hot Water System?

A gas hot water system heats water using natural gas or LPG (Liquid Petroleum Gas). When you turn on your hot water tap, cold water flows into the hot water system where a gas burner heats it up straight away. If you're using a storage hot water system, the gas burner keeps a tank of water hot and ready to use.

The key parts include:

• A gas burner that heats the water
• A storage tank (for storage hot water systems) or heat exchanger (for continuous flow)
• Temperature controls to keep the water at the right heat
• Gas connection and safety devices

‍

What Are The Differences Between Solar Hot Water Systems and Gas Hot Water Systems?

At Mitchell Plumbing & Gas, we regularly explain to Brisbane homeowners how solar and gas hot water systems differ in several key ways:

When looking at how these hot water systems create hot water, they use very different energy sources:

• Solar hot water systems collect energy from sunlight through roof-mounted panels
• Gas hot water systems burn natural gas or LPG to create heat
• Solar hot water systems need a backup power source for cloudy days
• Gas hot water systems work any time as long as there's a gas supply

The efficiency of both hot water systems varies in different ways:

• Solar hot water systems convert about 80% of sunlight into usable heat
• Gas hot water systems typically turn about 85% of gas into heat
• Solar efficiency changes with weather and seasons
• Gas hot water systems maintain steady efficiency year-round

The setup requirements for each hot water system have notable differences:

• Solar hot water systems need roof space and specific panel positioning
• Gas hot water systems are more flexible with installation locations
• Solar installations take longer and need more roof work
• Gas hot water systems often have simpler installation requirements

When comparing costs, several factors come into play:

• Solar hot water systems have higher upfront costs but lower running costs
• Gas hot water systems cost less to install but have ongoing gas bills
• Solar hot water systems might qualify for government rebates
• Gas prices can change, affecting long-term running costs

‍

Energy Efficiency Differences Between Solar and Gas Hot Water Systems

Solar hot water systems tap into free sunlight, converting about 80% of solar energy into heat for your water. On a sunny Brisbane day, these hot water systems work at their peak. However, their performance drops when it's cloudy, which is why they need backup heating elements.

Gas hot water systems use natural gas or LPG, turning about 85% of the gas energy into heat. This rate stays steady regardless of weather. The hot water system fires up whenever you need hot water, using only the gas needed to heat the water you're using.

Here's how the efficiency rates compare between both hot water systems:

• Solar hot water systems work best in summer with 80-90% efficiency
• Efficiency drops to 30-40% on overcast days
• Gas hot water systems maintain 85% efficiency year-round
• Gas efficiency isn't affected by weather

‍

Installation Costs Differences Between Solar and Gas Hot Water Systems

The installation costs of hot water hot water systems include everything needed to get your new hot water system up and running, from the unit price to labour and additional materials.

When it comes to initial purchase and setup costs, solar hot water systems are a bigger investment upfront, typically costing between $3,000 to $7,000 for a complete setup. This price includes the solar panels, storage tank, and all the mounting equipment needed for the roof installation. Gas hot water systems, on the other hand, usually range from $1,500 to $3,000 for installation, making them more budget-friendly at first.

There are several financial benefits that can help offset the cost of installation. Solar hot water systems qualify for Small-scale Technology Certificates (STCs), and Brisbane residents might access local council sustainability rebates. Some energy providers offer special solar installation discounts, while gas hot water systems occasionally have supplier promotional offers.

Looking at long-term costs, solar hot water systems save homeowners about $300-$700 yearly on energy bills because they use free sunlight. Gas hot water system running costs depend on changing gas prices, which can affect your monthly expenses. Solar maintenance costs stay lower over time, while gas hot water systems need regular gas supply payments.

‍

Required Maintenance Differences Between Solar and Gas Hot Water Systems

Maintenance is essential for keeping your hot water system working safely and efficiently. Each type of hot water system has its own maintenance needs and schedules.

Solar hot water systems need specific care but less frequent attention. The main tasks include cleaning the panels annually to remove dirt and debris, checking the solar collector every five years, and inspecting roof mounting points. The pressure relief valve needs testing every six months, and anodes should be replaced every five years.

Gas hot water systems require more regular attention to stay safe and efficient. This includes annual safety inspections of gas connections, checking burner operation every two years, and cleaning burner jets yearly. The pressure relief valve needs testing every six months, and thermocouples typically need replacement every two to three years.

The frequency of maintenance differs between the two hot water systems. Solar hot water systems only need major service every five years, with simple panel cleaning twice yearly. Gas hot water systems need more frequent attention, with yearly professional checks and regular safety inspections to ensure they're working safely and efficiently.

‍

Average Lifespan Differences Between Solar and Gas Hot Water Systems

A hot water system's lifespan refers to how long it will reliably provide hot water before needing replacement. This timeframe helps homeowners plan for future replacements and understand the long-term value of their investment.

Solar hot water systems typically last between 20 to 25 years when properly maintained. The solar panels themselves are highly durable and can withstand Australian weather conditions, while the storage tanks are built with corrosion-resistant materials. However, this lifespan can be shorter in coastal areas where salt air might affect the hot water system's components more quickly.

Gas hot water systems generally have a shorter lifespan of 10 to 15 years. This shorter life expectancy is mainly due to the constant exposure to heat from gas combustion and the regular wear on internal components. The actual lifespan of both hot water systems can vary based on water quality, usage patterns, and how well they're maintained.

Regular servicing, water quality, and climate conditions play significant roles in how long these hot water systems last. Hard water can reduce the lifespan of both hot water systems by causing mineral buildup, while proper maintenance can help them reach or even exceed their expected lifespans.

‍

Heat-up Time Differences Between Solar and Gas Hot Water Systems

Heat-up time is how long it takes for the hot water system to warm water to your desired temperature when you need hot water. This factor is particularly important for families who need hot water at different times throughout the day.

Solar hot water systems heat water gradually throughout the day as sunlight hits the solar collectors. On sunny days, these hot water systems maintain a steady supply of hot water. However, during cloudy weather or at night, the backup electric or gas booster might need to be activated, which can take 30-60 minutes to heat a full tank.

Gas hot water systems provide much quicker heating, typically taking only a few minutes to heat water from cold to hot. Continuous flow gas hot water systems heat water instantly as it passes through the unit, while storage tank hot water systems maintain hot water at a set temperature all day.

The consistency of heating is a key difference between these hot water systems. Gas hot water systems provide reliable heat-up times regardless of weather or time of day. Solar hot water systems, while energy-efficient, depend more on weather conditions and daylight hours, which can affect their heat-up performance.

‍

Noise Levels Differences Between Solar and Gas Hot Water Systems

Noise levels in hot water systems refer to the sound produced during operation, which can affect the comfort of people living in or near the home. Understanding these noise differences helps in deciding where to place your hot water system.

Solar hot water systems run almost silently because they have very few moving parts. The only noticeable sound comes from water movement through the pipes and occasional clicking from the backup electric booster when it activates. These hot water systems are ideal for installation near bedrooms or living areas because they won't disturb your daily activities.

Gas hot water systems produce more noticeable sounds during operation. When the burner ignites, you might hear a distinctive whooshing sound, and there's often a low humming noise while the hot water system is heating water. Storage hot water systems can also make occasional clicking sounds as they maintain water temperature throughout the day.

The location of your hot water system, pipe insulation quality, and hot water system age can all affect noise levels. Older hot water systems typically become noisier over time, and poorly installed pipes might create water hammer sounds in both types of hot water systems.

‍

Environmental Impact Differences Between Solar and Gas Hot Water Systems

Solar hot water systems stand out for their environmental benefits as they harness renewable energy from the sun. These hot water systems produce no direct carbon emissions during operation, making them an environmentally responsible choice for Brisbane homes. The only environmental impact comes from the manufacturing process and the occasional use of the backup heating system.

Gas hot water systems have a larger environmental footprint because they burn fossil fuels to heat water. Each time the hot water system operates, it releases carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases into the atmosphere. While newer gas hot water systems are more efficient and produce fewer emissions than older models, they still contribute to household carbon emissions.

Modern gas hot water systems have improved their environmental performance through better insulation and more efficient burning processes. However, they can't match the minimal environmental impact of solar hot water systems, which use clean, renewable energy for most of their operation.

‍

What Are The Overall Pros And Cons When Comparing Solar and Gas Hot Water Systems?

Here's what we consider the key advantages and disadvantages of each hot water system based on our experience servicing Brisbane homes:

When looking at the overall performance of solar hot water systems, these are the main points to consider:

• Works best in sunny Brisbane conditions
• Higher upfront installation costs
• Near-silent operation
• Significant energy bill savings
• Minimal environmental impact
• Needs backup hot water system for cloudy days
• Takes longer to heat water
• More complex installation process

For gas hot water systems, here are the key factors that affect their performance:

• Quick and consistent water heating
• Lower initial setup costs
• Some operational noise
• Ongoing gas bill expenses
• Produces carbon emissions
• Simple installation process
• Shorter hot water system lifespan
• Works in any weather

‍

What Are The Advantages Of Solar Hot Water Systems When Compared To Gas Hot Water Systems?

Solar hot water systems offer several benefits that make them an attractive option for Brisbane homeowners, especially those looking to reduce their environmental impact and long-term costs.

Here are the main benefits that set solar hot water systems apart:

• Cut energy bills by up to 80% once installed
• Use free solar energy instead of paid gas supply
• Create no carbon emissions during operation
• Qualify for government rebates and incentives
• Last longer than gas hot water systems
• Need less frequent maintenance
• Work well in Brisbane's sunny climate
• Add value to your property

‍

What Are The Advantages Of Gas Hot Water Systems When Compared To Solar Hot Water Systems?

Gas hot water systems have distinct benefits that make them suitable for certain households, particularly those needing reliable hot water access regardless of weather conditions.

These are the key advantages of choosing a gas hot water system:

• Heats water quickly when needed
• Works consistently day and night
• Costs less to purchase and install
• Suits homes with limited roof space
• Easy to replace existing gas hot water systems
• Provides endless hot water with continuous flow models
• Simple to maintain and service
• Can be installed almost anywhere around the home

‍