Solar Hot Water Systems vs Electric Hot Water Systems

When choosing a hot water system for your Brisbane home, it's important to understand how solar and electric hot water systems work. Mitchell Plumbing & Gas helps homeowners make informed decisions about their hot water needs.

A solar hot water system uses the sun's energy to heat water through panels or tubes installed on your roof. These panels collect sunlight and transfer the heat to water stored in a tank. The heated water is then ready for use in your home's taps and appliances.

An electric hot water system heats water using an electric element, much like a kettle. The element sits inside a storage tank and heats the water to your desired temperature. It's a straightforward hot water system that has been used in Australian homes for many years.

Solar and electric hot water systems each bring different benefits to your home. While solar hot water systems harness natural energy and save money long-term, electric hot water systems offer reliability and simpler setup. Understanding these differences helps you pick the hot water system that best matches your household's needs. Here's how they measure up in important areas.

• Energy Use and Running Costs: Solar hot water systems use free energy from the sun, which makes them cheaper to run. While they need a small amount of electricity as a backup on cloudy days, their running costs are much lower than electric hot water systems. Electric hot water systems use more energy because they rely entirely on electricity to heat water.
• Installation Costs: The upfront cost of solar hot water systems is higher because of the panels, tank, and more complex installation process. Electric hot water systems are cheaper to buy and install because they're simpler. The initial investment varies based on hot water system size and home requirements.
• Maintenance Requirements: Solar hot water systems need regular checks of the panels and moving parts. We recommend having the panels cleaned and the hot water system serviced yearly. Electric hot water systems are simpler to maintain, usually only needing attention if something goes wrong.
• System Lifespan: Solar hot water systems typically last 15-20 years when well-maintained. The panels are built to withstand Australian weather conditions. Electric hot water systems usually last 10-15 years, depending on water quality and usage patterns.
• Heat-Up Time: Electric hot water systems heat water quickly and consistently. Solar hot water systems depend on available sunlight, so heating times vary with weather conditions. However, the storage tank means you'll usually have hot water ready when you need it.
• Noise Levels: Both hot water systems are quiet. Solar hot water systems make minimal noise as water moves through the panels. Electric hot water systems occasionally make slight humming sounds when the element is heating.

‍

What Is A Solar Hot Water System? 

A solar hot water system is a water heating setup that turns sunlight into heat for your home's water supply. This hot water system catches the sun's warmth through collectors fixed on your roof. Inside these collectors, there's a special fluid that warms up in the sunlight. As this fluid gets hot, it moves down into a tank and passes its heat to your household water.

The main parts of a solar hot water system are:

• Solar collectors (flat panels or tubes) that soak up the sun's heat
• A storage tank with special insulation to keep water hot
• Pipes that connect the collectors to your tank
• A pump that moves the heating fluid through the hot water system
• A controller that manages the whole process

‍

What Is An Electric Hot Water System? 

An electric hot water system is a water heater that uses electrical power to warm your water. The hot water system works by passing electricity through heating elements inside a tank. These elements heat up like a big kettle and warm the surrounding water to the temperature you want.

The main parts of an electric hot water system are:

• An insulated storage tank that holds the water
• One or two heating elements that warm the water
• A thermostat that keeps track of water temperature
• Cold water inlet and hot water outlet pipes
• A temperature pressure relief valve for safety

‍

What Are The Differences Between Solar And Electric Hot Water Systems?

The main differences between solar and electric hot water systems show up in how they work, what powers them, and what they cost to run and install.

• Energy Source: Solar hot water systems mainly use free sunlight to heat water, with electricity only as a backup. Electric hot water systems rely completely on grid electricity, which means ongoing power bills.
• Efficiency: Solar hot water systems turn about 80% of sunlight into heat energy on clear days. Electric hot water systems are nearly 95% efficient at turning electricity into heat, but this comes at a higher running cost.
• Installation Process: Solar hot water systems need roof access and more complex setup work. Panels must face the right way to catch maximum sunlight. Electric hot water systems are simpler to install as they only need a power connection and water pipes.
• Cost: Solar hot water systems cost more upfront but save money over time through lower bills. Electric hot water systems are cheaper to buy and install but cost more to run year after year.

‍

Energy Efficiency Differences Between Solar And Electric Hot Water Systems

Solar hot water systems use the sun's free energy as their main power source. These hot water systems convert about 80% of sunlight into usable heat on sunny days. This efficiency drops on cloudy days or during winter when there's less sunlight. At these times, the backup electric element kicks in to maintain hot water supply.

Electric hot water systems run solely on grid electricity. They turn about 95% of electrical energy into heat. This high efficiency stays the same all year round because it doesn't depend on weather. However, this consistent performance comes with higher energy bills as you're paying for every bit of hot water.

When it comes to turning energy into hot water, solar and electric hot water systems each have their own efficiency story. Solar systems make the most of free sunlight but change with weather conditions, while electric hot water systems offer steady performance at a higher running cost. Let's look at how each hot water system measures up.

• Solar hot water systems work best in sunny weather and their performance changes with cloud cover
• Electric hot water systems work the same way no matter what the weather's like
• Solar efficiency drops by about 40-50% on very cloudy days
• Electric hot water systems keep their high efficiency in all conditions

‍

Installation Cost Differences Between Solar And Electric Hot Water Systems

Installation costs cover everything needed to get your hot water system working safely in your home, from the equipment itself to the professional labour required. Solar hot water systems typically come with a higher upfront cost, ranging from $3,000 to $7,000, because they need rooftop collectors, storage tanks, and more complex installation work. Their placement also needs careful planning to maximise sun exposure.

Electric hot water systems have a lower initial cost of $800 to $2,000 because they need simpler equipment and installation work. The hot water system mainly consists of the storage tank and basic plumbing connections, making it straightforward to install in most homes.

For solar hot water systems, government rebates like Small-scale Technology Certificates (STCs) can help reduce the upfront cost. These incentives are part of Australia's renewable energy initiatives, making solar hot water systems more affordable for homeowners.

Over time, solar hot water systems prove more cost-effective. The free energy from the sun means lower electricity bills, often saving hundreds of dollars each year. Electric hot water systems, while cheaper to install, cost more to run because they rely entirely on grid electricity, leading to higher ongoing energy bills.

‍

Required Maintenance Differences Between Solar And Electric Hot Water Systems

Maintenance means keeping your hot water system working safely and efficiently through regular checks and servicing. This helps prevent breakdowns and extends the hot water system's life.

Solar hot water systems need checking once a year. The main focus is keeping the solar collectors clean and clear of debris for maximum sun absorption. A qualified technician should inspect the roof mounting, tank insulation, and pipe connections to ensure everything works properly. The backup electric element also needs occasional checking.

Electric hot water systems need more frequent attention because they work harder to heat water. Every six months, the hot water system needs checking for leaks, proper pressure levels, and element function. The anode rod, which prevents tank corrosion, needs replacement every 4-5 years. Regular maintenance helps catch small issues before they become expensive problems.

‍

Average Lifespan Differences Between Solar And Electric Hot Water Systems

The lifespan of a hot water system measures the time from installation until the hot water system needs replacement due to decreased heating efficiency or safety concerns. Solar hot water systems typically last 20-25 years because of their durable construction and fewer moving parts. The solar collectors and tanks are built with materials that withstand Australian weather conditions, which helps them maintain performance over many years.

Electric hot water systems have a shorter lifespan of 10-15 years due to constant internal stress from heating elements. These hot water systems work harder because they're heating water from scratch each time, which causes more wear on components. The heating elements and internal tank walls experience regular stress from heating cycles, leading to eventual breakdown or inefficiency.

Several factors influence how long both hot water systems last. Water quality affects internal components, with high mineral content potentially shortening hot water system life. Usage patterns matter too – homes with higher hot water demands place more stress on their hot water systems. Regular maintenance plays a big role, as neglected hot water systems often fail earlier. The quality of the initial installation also impacts longevity, making professional installation important for both types.

‍

Heat-Up Time Differences Between Solar And Electric Hot Water Systems

Heat-up time shows how quickly your hot water system can warm cold water to usable temperatures for your daily needs. Solar hot water systems take 4-8 hours to heat water on sunny days, with longer times during cloudy weather. Morning hot water availability depends heavily on the previous day's sun exposure, and the hot water system might need its backup electric element during poor weather.

Electric hot water systems deliver more predictable heat-up times, typically warming cold water in 1-2 hours. This consistent performance happens regardless of weather or time of day. When hot water demand is high, electric hot water systems recover quickly, heating new water at the same steady rate. Their heating speed stays reliable throughout the year, unaffected by seasonal changes or weather patterns.

Daily performance varies between the hot water systems. Solar units excel during sunny days but rely on stored hot water for night use. They might need backup heating during extended cloudy periods. Electric hot water systems maintain steady heating speeds around the clock, providing reliable hot water whenever needed. This consistency makes electric hot water systems more predictable for daily use, though at a higher energy cost.

‍

Noise Level Differences Between Solar And Electric Hot Water Systems

Noise levels in hot water systems refer to the sounds produced during operation, which can affect your home's comfort. Solar hot water systems run quietly because they have few moving parts. The main sound comes from water moving through the panels and the occasional operation of the small pump that circulates water. These gentle noises blend into the background of daily household activities.

Electric hot water systems make more noticeable sounds during operation. When the heating elements turn on, you might hear a low humming noise, along with occasional clicking as the hot water system regulates temperature. Water movement inside the tank can create subtle expansion sounds as it heats. These sounds are generally not disruptive but might be more noticeable in quiet areas or if the hot water system is near living spaces.

‍

Environmental Impact Differences Between Solar And Electric Hot Water Systems

Solar hot water systems stand out for their environmental benefits. They use renewable energy from the sun as their primary heat source, which creates no carbon emissions during operation. The only environmental impact comes from the small amount of backup electricity used on cloudy days or at night. This significantly reduces a household's carbon footprint and helps preserve natural resources.

Electric hot water systems have a larger environmental footprint. They rely completely on grid electricity, which often comes from coal or gas power stations. This means every litre of hot water contributes to carbon emissions. While newer electric hot water systems are more energy-efficient than older models, they still consume significant amounts of electricity, making them less environmentally friendly than solar alternatives. An average electric hot water system can generate up to 3 tonnes of carbon emissions each year, while a solar hot water system produces much less, helping Australian homes reduce their impact on climate change.

‍

What Are The Overall Pros And Cons When Comparing Solar And Electric Hot Water Systems?

A clear comparison of both systems helps understand their strengths and limitations across different aspects:

Solar Hot Water Systems:

• Efficiency: Uses free solar energy with 80% conversion rate
• Installation: Complex setup requiring professional installation
• Cost: High upfront cost but lower running costs
• Noise: Almost silent operation
• Environmental Impact: Zero emissions during solar operation

Electric Hot Water Systems:

• Efficiency: 95% energy conversion but uses paid electricity
• Installation: Simple setup with basic plumbing needed
• Cost: Lower upfront cost but higher running costs
• Noise: Low humming during heating cycles
• Environmental Impact: Higher carbon emissions from grid power

‍

What Are The Advantages Of Solar Hot Water Systems?

Solar hot water systems provide several advantages when compared to electric hot water systems:

Higher Energy Savings:

• Cut energy bills by up to 80%
• Protection against rising electricity prices
• Minimal ongoing running costs
• Free energy from the sun
• Return on investment within 5-7 years

Environmentally Friendly:

• Zero emissions during solar operation
• Uses renewable energy source
• Reduces household carbon footprint
• Supports sustainable living
• Less reliance on grid power

‍

What Are The Advantages Of Electric Hot Water Systems?

Electric hot water systems offer distinct benefits in certain situations:

Consistent Performance:

• Reliable hot water delivery
• Works in all weather conditions
• Fast heat-up times
• Even water temperature
• No reliance on sunlight

Practical Benefits:

• Lower upfront purchase costs
• Simple installation process
• Works in any location
• No roof space needed
• Easy maintenance access

‍